Do Not Pass Go is just over a year old and it’s no stretch to say that the past seven days were the most eventful yet in our short history, as far as competition in Canada is concerned.
The week kicked off with QUEBECOR announcing a surprise $31 billion takeover offer for fellow telecom incumbent TELUS. That was followed shortly after by a statement from Industry Minister Melanie Joly that, rather than outright condemning such a deal, was surprisingly warm to it.
Prime Minister Mark Carney compounded that sentiment mid-week while in China when he told reporters that oligopolies can actually be good for competition.
“Depending on the market structure, the form of oligopoly can lead to more competition with fewer players under certain circumstances,” he said. “So it depends on the market structure aspect of it and we need to take an informed decision on that.”
And to add the cherry on top of it all, BELL is now considering making an offer for Telus. Woof.
Whether it’s news outlets, Bay Street analysts or the internet in general, people have thoughts. And they should. A takeover of Telus by either Quebecor or Bell would represent one of the biggest mergers in the nation’s history, more valuable in dollars than even Rogers’ purchase of Shaw in 2023. Never mind that it would happen in the one sector that immediately comes to mind when hearing the word “oligopoly.”
The take I’ve liked most so far comes from Globe and Mail columnist Rita Trichur, who wrote on Tuesday that Quebecor has done Canada a favour because it finally moves the simmering conflict between sovereignty and competition to the forefront of public consciousness.
“Regardless of the deal’s probability of success, Quebecor’s takeover offer for Telus forces the federal government to publicly interrogate the assumption that encouraging new national champions would create prosperity for all Canadians,” Trichur writes. “This is a national debate that is long overdue and one that ought to involve ordinary Canadians in addition to business leaders, lawyers and legislators.”
We’ve covered this quite a bit here over the past few months – that Carney and his government have been trying to have it both ways by pushing big national champions while at the same time insisting that they want more competition within Canada’s many oligopolized industries.
It’s now up to Carney – who often either gets praised for being the smartest guy in the room, or criticized for trying to be that – to explain the apparent incongruity.
How exactly can an oligopoly produce better outcomes for consumers, and what is the market structure he’s referring to? I’ve asked his office for elucidation but have not received a response. I’ve also invited Carney onto the Do Not Pass Go podcast several times, but it’s been a “no” so far.
The Wholesale Debacle
Absent further explanation from the PM himself, we can imagine at least two structures under which his thesis could be correct. The first is strong price regulation, as in the government via the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission (CRTC) setting the prices of telecom services.
That’s a scoff-worthy suggestion, but it’s already happening, sort of – on the wholesale level. For longer than perhaps anyone can remember, independent internet providers have enjoyed mandated access to networks owned by the big guys including Bell, Rogers, Telus and Quebecor, at rates set by the CRTC.
How this works is the CRTC assesses what it costs those big companies to provide network access, then adds a suitable markup, and voila – that’s the rate indie ISPs such as TekSavvy or National Capital Freenet pay them. The indies then tack on their own costs, which include marketing, bandwidth and, of course, the legal departments necessary to navigate the regulatory landscape, plus (hopefully) a profit margin, and boom – that’s the price they offer service at to customers.
In theory, their prices should be lower than the big guys, who historically take larger profit margins, and that is supposed to discipline what those incumbents charge. Consumers therefore benefit whether they are customers of the indies or not, which means the CRTC does indeed indirectly influence the prices that most Canadians pay for internet service.
In reality, there is perhaps no bigger regulatory cluster you-know-what in Canada than this wholesale regime. The indies and incumbents have been arguing over what those wholesale rates should be for well over a decade, a period that has been punctuated by intense lobbying, cabinet and court appeals, and banana republic-style regulatory capture that has included Bell’s CEO having chummy beers with the CRTC chair in an Ottawa pub.
The result is most indies going belly up over the past few years, with the remaining providers often perversely being forced to charge more for services than the companies they’re supposed to be disciplining. Canadians, meanwhile, continue to pay some of the highest prices in the developed world.
A similar wholesale system exists in wireless, but amazingly, it’s even worse. Here, independent competitors must buy wireless spectrum – a public asset that can only be had through shelling out billions of dollars through rare auctions – and commit to building their own physical networks if they want to first use those owned by incumbents.
Not surprisingly, there’s been almost no take-up of this regime, with only regional cable provider Cogeco making a go of it.
Assuming Carney doesn’t want to fully regulate retail prices of telecom services in Canada, one possible avenue for creating better outcomes and prices for consumers while simultaneously allowing the oligopoly to shrink further would be to straighten out this wholesale mess.
That would involve dropping both the onerous restrictions on smaller companies to get into wireless and significantly lowering wholesale access prices in broadband.
The problem is that the incumbents view the entire concept of wholesale as an undesirable wart on their figurative backsides and, as we’ve seen, have fought with every tool at their disposal to defeat, delay or water it down.
Anyone not involved in buying Telus will continue to do so, and will likely succeed. The CRTC, which is in charge of it all, has shown it is woefully unable to sort it all out, which is why organizations such as the Internet Society have called for it to reformed outright.
An Insufficient Defence
The other factor that the Prime Minister could be referring to in suggesting that an oligopoly can actually lead to better outcomes for consumers is the efficiencies defence – an aspect of competition law that large Canadian companies have historically used as a rationale for merging.
As the argument goes, merging companies can become more efficient by cutting redundant costs, which includes employees, marketing, offices and other physical locations. Those cost savings can then be passed on to consumers in the form of lower prices.
In reality, as too many studies to count have shown, it doesn’t happen. Companies may realize cost savings through merging, but they almost never pass those on to consumers. Why would they when they can keep them as profits?
Which is why Canada – under Carney’s predecessor Justin Trudeau – in 2023 eliminated this artifact of neoliberal thinking from the Competition Act. It was simply proven not to work.
That old approach has been giving way globally to a newer anti-monopoly movement – something old school adherents often refer to as “hipster antitrust,” which opposes concentrated corporate power and stricter enforcement against large companies.
Donald Trump stopped that momentum nearly dead in the United States when he took office for the second time, but as I’ve now mentioned here a few times, the prominence of antitrust and affordability issues in the recent mid-term elections suggest the movement is about to resume there.
Judging by what cannot be overstated as public shock and even outrage over Quebecor’s bid for Telus and the Canadian government’s accommodating response to it so far, it’s about to resume here too.
It’s entirely possible that Carney had something completely different in mind when he suggested that oligopolies can lead to more competition.
But if counting on the CRTC to fix the telecom market or going backwards to resurrect the efficiencies defence as a way of allowing another telecom mega-merger are it, then Canadians have a right to be very concerned.
🎧 ON THE PODCAST THIS WEEK:
The Price is Whatever They Think You'll Pay
Cornering the market and eliminating the competition, hiding the price of goods, adding all manner of junk fees, spying on you and using your own data against you – this is just a partial list of how modern merchants are extracting every penny they can, and want, from consumers.
📱 TELECOM
The sovereignty-flavoured side show to the above is SpaceX, with Quebecor chief executive Pierre Karl Peladeau invoking the Elon Musk-owned company as the bogeyman that his merger is designed to ward off.
In making his pitch this week, Peladeau said SpaceX and its Starlink subsidiary are coming to eat Canadian telcos’ lunch with its satellite-delivered broadband and wireless services, and this is bad because Canada obviously wants its telecom providers to be domestically owned.
His argument would be transparently self-serving if it wasn’t for the fact that Canada’s own satellite alternatives are in such bad shape. First up is XPLORE, which this week was granted creditor protection by the Ontario Superior Court of Justice after it missed two loan payments.
The company, formerly known as Xplornet, had been Canada’s original satellite-based internet provider until Starlink came along with its low earth-orbit (LEO) network. The New Brunswick-based company hasn’t been able to keep pace and is in the midst of restructuring.
Meanwhile, TELESAT also this week announced that a group of its lenders have agreed to hold off on collecting their first big chunk of debt, which had been due Dec. 6, until Jan. 18.
The Ottawa-based company, which provides backhaul and network services for other telecom operators, enterprises and governments, is also having a debt crunch as it tries to transition from its traditional satellite business to a more modern LEO network.
Meanwhile, Prime Minister Mark Carney has asked the Ethics Commissioner to implement a conflict-of-interest screen between himself and Telesat CEO Dan Goldberg. The two have been good friends for several decades, with the screening request coming shortly after the Conservatives asked for the Commissioner to assess whether Carney had broken the Conflict of Interest Act.
Telesat received a $2.3 billion contract from the federal government in August, though Carney said he was not involved.
Besides being the recipient of an unexpected takeover offer, TELUS was also in the news this week for announcing that it was abandoning plans to build two AI data centres in Vancouver. No reason was given for the reversal, leading local city councillors to wonder if Telus didn’t want to take a reputational hit from the growing public backlash against data centres. WESTBANK, the developer of the planned centres, says it has already found a replacement partner, though it did not specify who.
The Competition Tribunal this week hit ROGERS with $500,000 in legal costs related to its recent false advertising case. The fees are in addition to the $15 million penalty levied by the Tribunal in the case brought by the Competition Bureau, which successfully argued that Rogers had misled consumers by advertising “unlimited” data plans that were actually quite limited.
COMPETITION COMMISSIONER WATCH
Welcome to our brand new feature: the Competition Commissioner Watch, a running tally on how long the federal government has avoided hiring a full-time Competition Commissioner to replace Matthew Boswell, who stepped down from the job on Dec. 17, 2025:

🏈 SPORTS & ENTERTAINMENT
The release of Grand Theft Auto VI was obviously the big video game news of the week, but running a close second was SONY’s win in an antitrust case.
The U.K.’s Competition Appeal Tribunal dismissed a case against the company that alleged it was using its control over digital PlayStation sales to unfairly raise prices on games. The £2 billion class-action, brought by consumer advocates, argued that Sony was abusing its dominant position by requiring digital games and add-ons for its console to be bought and sold only through its PlayStation store, which was making prices higher than for physical games.
Sony convinced the Tribunal that the market was competitive, with rivals Microsoft and Nintendo using similar models, and that the margins it was collecting were not excessive.
The case had many eyeballs on it, given Sony’s recent announcement that it will discontinue making game discs in 2028, with an inevitable push to go all digital coming.
More job cuts in the Canadian video game industry, with France’s UBISOFT axing another 166 positions at studios in Montreal and Quebec City.
Fans of the sexy hockey-themed TV shows and/or classic board games have reason to rejoice, with a new Heated Rivalry version of Monopoly coming soon. Playing pieces include Straw+Berry smoothie, hockey skate and MLH Cup tokens, while the board will feature locations from the show. The game will be released May 1. Do not pass go indeed!
For more on the TELUS story and Canada’s darkening competition situation, check out Canadian Anti-Monopoly Project executive director Keldon Bestor on BNN Bloomberg this week:
🩺 HEALTH
The Competition Bureau has dropped its investigation into Express Scripts Canada, one of the country’s largest pharmacy benefits managers (PBM), though it remains “concerned about the potential harm to competition” by the company’s ability to direct consumers’ insurance claims.
PBMs are third-party administrators that manage prescription drug benefits on behalf of insurers, employers and government health plans. In Canada, they have increasingly been adopting so-called preferred pharmacy networks, a controversial deal in which the PBM requires people to visit specific drugstores in order to be reimbursed for their medications.
The Bureau began investigating Express Scripts, which is owned by U.S. insurance company CIGNA, in 2024, but says it did not find sufficient evidence of abuse of dominance to support further enforcement.
🛒 RETAIL
On the flip side of enforcement, the Competition Bureau this week announced it has received a court order that will allow it to advance its investigation into marketing tactics being used by Old Navy and The Gap.
The Bureau is looking into whether the retail chains, both of which are owned by San Francisco-based GAP INC., are deceiving consumers through urgency cues such as limited-time offers and countdown timers, messages that suggest products are “selling fast” or have “only a few left,” popularity representations such as the number of people who are viewing or purchasing a product, and claims about past prices or discounts.
The Bureau says it began looking into the chains’ practices after receiving a surge in complaints about inflated prices. The company says it is co-operating with the investigation.
🚨 COMING UP
Fresh off sold-out runs in Winnipeg and Ottawa, the hit one-man play ROGERS V. ROGERS has returned to Toronto. This Tuesday, we’ve got a very special Do Not Pass Go podcast episode recorded live at Canadian Stage. We’re in conversation with playwright MICHAEL HEALEY and Globe and Mail reporter ALEXANDRA POSADZKI, author of the book the play is based on. We talk telecom mergers, the Competition Bureau and chicken McNuggets. Don’t you dare miss it!





Engaging story and very clearly written.
File a complaint about the proposed merger here with the competition bureau
https://competition-bureau.canada.ca/en/contact-competition-bureau-canada/merger-review-process-and-feedback-form